web analytics

Proving Liability in Slip & Fall Cases

I recently recovered $150,000 for a Luzerne County woman who slipped and fell on ice and fractured her right ankle. The recovery was significant because the injured person fell days after a major snowstorm hit the region. Liability was extremely difficult to prove.  However, through discovery I was able to prove that the owner of the property did not properly shovel and salt his walkways that morning. 

The property owner tried to argue that he should not be responsible for what happened because he applied some salt to the walkway that morning.  The property owner was relying upon the Hills and Ridges Doctrine in Pennsylvania.  Fortunately, when ice is left behind after human intervention, such as salting or shoveling, which can result in a remelt, it is no longer the result of an entirely natural accumulation and the property owners cannot raise the Hills and Ridges Doctrine as a defense.  See Harvey v. Rouse Chamberlin, LTD., 901 A.2d 523 (Pa. Super. 2006).  Therefore, the property owner could not successfully assert this defense.

20th Annual Ride to Work Day

June 20, 2011 is the 20th Annual “Ride to Work Day”.  On this day more than twice the normal number of motorcycle riders are expected to join.  Stark & Stark believes “Ride to Work Day” is an important day for showcasing motorcycles and to protect and promote motorcycle riding With more motorcycles on the road, riders become more visible to motor vehicle drivers which makes them more aware of the presence of motorcycles. 

Along those lines The Riders Lawyers at Stark & Stark want to remind you to ride safely.  Specifically, when you are riding with passengers on your bike keep in mind that you should consider certain adjustments to your bike such as the tire pressure and suspension settings.  In addition, the extra weight of the passenger will tend to make motorcycles slower to respond to steering and may require more throttle to start. In addition,  greater brake pressure will be needed to slow and stop and cornering clearance will be reduced because of the passenger’s extra weight.

As always Stark & Stark encourages safe and responsible riding and urges you to ride you motorcycle on “Ride to Work Day” to make all road users conscious of motorcycles and increase safety for motorcycles on the roadway.

It's Time for Your Deposition: What will happen, and why?

A deposition is a question and answer conversation that is recorded by a stenographer before any trial takes place. During a deposition, the opposing counsel will ask questions and you will provide the answers. The deposition is conducted as part of the lawsuit process and therefore, the Defendant has the right to take your deposition.

Why does the defendant want to take your deposition?

To get information that affects your claim: At the time your deposition is taken, the Defendant will already have most of the information which impacts on your claim. This is their chance to confirm the information provided is complete and that they have everything needed to evaluate your claim.

To evaluate your believability/credibility: This is the Defendant’s chance to see you and hear you.  In evaluating any claim, the Defendant wants to know if the person bringing a claim will present a believable and credible story to a jury.  They know if a jury likes you and believes you, they are likely to look favorably on your claim.

How do you present believable/credible testimony:

  • Relax - Most people will be nervous about the deposition.  Remember, it is just a question and answer conversation.  The defense attorney is not a mean person, but is simply trying to get information that effects your claim.
  • Tell the Truth - You are under oath and your answers have the same effect as if you were testifying in court before a judge or a jury.
  • Answer the Question -  Answer only the question.  In normal conversations, we often give more of an answer than the question asks; or we answer the question we thought the person was trying to ask; or we give an answer that we want to give regardless of the question.  Remember, this is not a normal conversation.  It is a question and answer session. Listen to the question and provide your truthful and honest response to the question.
  • It is okay to say you cannot recall - This is not a memory test.  You are not expected to know every date, time and place.
  • Do Not Guess - Remember, you are answering under oath.

Claim Assessment Software Places Premium on Communication with Doctors

These days nearly every major insurance carrier utilizes some form of claim assessment software for the purpose of evaluating bodily injury claims.  The purpose of this software is to take the guess work out of the claims evaluation process by breaking each claim down into factors that can be evaluated identically regardless of the adjuster or the claimant.  Generally, once an adjuster receives a demand letter from an attorney, they simply input the information contained within this letter into the claim assessment program.  The program then calculates a value range for the claim and the adjuster is tasked with the responsibility of settling the case within this range.

As plaintiff’s attorneys have gained a better understanding of the inner workings of these claim assessment programs they have begun to adjust their practices accordingly.  For instance, many attorney’s are now making a concerted effort to create demand letters that specifically address the factors that are used by claims assessment software to evaluate claims.  These factors include, but are not limited to a detailed description of all injuries and complaints of pain, treatment received, duration of symptoms, pain experienced while performing various activities and loss of enjoyment of life. 

However, simply mentioning these factors in a demand letter is not sufficient.  For the most part, all factors must be documented by a treating physician before an adjustor will input them into the claims assessment program.  This is where communication with a treating physician can prove vital in increasing the value of a claim.  In my practice, I find that physicians will generally make reference to factors such as injuries, complaints, treatment and duration of symptoms.  Despite this, it is still essential that a patient communicate all of their injuries and complaints of pain with their physician to ensure that these factors are adequately noted.  More importantly, I frequently find that physicians will fail to adequately note a patient’s pain while performing specific activities and loss of enjoyment of life unless these factors are specifically mentioned by the patient.  This is why I encourage all of my clients to make a point of openly communicating with their physicians regarding all of the ways in which their injuries have impacted their lives.

Some examples of factors that can drive up the value of a claim if properly documented are working or attending classes while in pain and performing household chores such as laundry, vacuuming, landscaping and mowing the lawn despite pain.  Any limitations and/or inability to perform any of these activities due to pain will also add to the value of a claim, as will limitations and/or inability to participate in recreational activities such as sports, workouts or travel.

Damages Recoverable in Personal Injury Lawsuit: Economic Damages, Past and Future Wage Loss

In addition to the NON-ECONOMIC damages (pain and suffering), an injured party is entitled to be reimbursed for the ECONOMIC losses they have suffered. Economic losses are those losses that are tangible and capable of specific calculation or projection. They generally fall into the following categories: past and future wage loss, past and future medical bills, and medical expenses. In this blog entry, I will discuss past and future wage loss.

Past Wage Loss: This damage is the amount of money that an injured party has lost because he or she has been unable to work as a result of their injury. Usually, past wage loss is easy to calculate, especially if the injured party is paid a salary or paid by the hour. Past wage loss is more difficult to calculate if the injured party is paid by commission. However, even in that circumstance a calculation can be made by looking at the past earnings historically, often over a course of months or years, and using the historical data to estimate the actual loss.

Future Wage Loss: This damage is the amount of wage loss that is projected to be lost in the future as a result of ongoing disability. Generally, attorneys will use vocational experts as well as economists to review each case individually and project how a given party’s injury will affect their ability to work indefinitely (total disability) or for some period of time or in some diminished capacity (partial disability). The experts will take into consideration not only the persons past history but also the person age, work life expectancy, and ability to do work other than the work they were doing before their injury.

Proposed Legislation in Pennsylvania Would Change Joint and Several Law in Pennsylvania

Kyle Hoff, who was seriously injured in a construction accident, speaks out in the below video against the Pennsylvania Legislature’s recent decision change joint and several law in Pennsylvania. Kyle made the video in an effort to protect important legal rights for victims of dangerous products. In the video, Kyle urges the residents of Pennsylvania to contact their senators and urge them to vote against Senate Bill 2. Help him tell the Pennsylvania Senate to preserve joint and several liability by stopping Senate Bill 2.

We’re trying to spread the video far and wide in an effort to develop opposition to this legislation. You can make a big difference by helping injured worker Kyle Hoff in his fight to preserve joint and several liability for future victims.

Limited Tort and Full Tort Car Insurance

I know, I know: I have discussed this topic before. In these economic times however, in an effort to save costs, I see more and more families change their car insurance from FULL TORT to limited tort. I am writing again, to suggest that you should keep the FULL TORT option if you have it and get the FULL TORT option if you don’t have it.

In my experience, insurance agents sell you on the limited tort option in order to provide a lower premium on your insurance policy. While this is true, be cautious as the savings between limited tort and FULL TORT may not be as significant as you think.

In the last month I have had six people call me who were involved in motor vehicle accidents. None of them caused the accident or were at fault for the accident in any way. All of the people were injured in some way, mostly having neck pain and back pain on a daily basis due to the accident. And all of these people had the limited tort option on their automobile policy. What most people don’t know is that if you have limited tort on your policy, you CANNOT get a recovery from the driver who caused the accident unless you are seriously or permanently injured. What most people also do not know is that the law is strict on what is considered a serious and permanent injury.

Generally, having neck or back pain is not enough to overcome limited tort in order to get a recovery for pain and suffering. Your injuries would need to be more serious like requiring surgery or causing you to be disabled in some capacity for the rest of your life. So even though you did not cause the accident and you have daily pain and may need medications, you may still NOT be entitled to a recovery if you have limited tort.

To protect yourself, you should purchase the FULL TORT option for your insurance. This means that you have preserved your right to a recovery for pain and suffering regardless of how injured you are. Also note however, that FULL TORT does not mean you have full coverage. You can have the FULL TORT option on your policy but not have other coverages you may need to protect you and your family such as underinsured or uninsured motorist coverage.

If you are going to purchase insurance for your car or your car insurance is up for renewal, feel for to call my office and we will review and discuss your policy for free! Just call us at   267-907-9600.

Can a Wife Recover for Injuries Sustained as a Result of Her Husband's Negligence in Pennsylvania?

Under Pennsylvania Law, the answer is: YES.

Recently, I met with a new client here in Bucks County, Pennsylvania, who sustained a serious injury in a motor vehicle accident as a result of the negligence of her husband. My client was a front seat passenger in a vehicle driven by her husband. Unfortunately, the husband was not paying attention to the traffic conditions and rear-ended another car in front of my client and her husband.

At our initial meeting my client said, “I know there is not much you can do because my husband caused the accident.” My client was under the mistaken impression that she could not recover damages for injuries caused by her husband’s negligence. Fortunately for my client, this is not the case under Pennsylvania Law.

In Hack v. Hack, 443 A.2d 859 (Pa. 1981), the Pennsylvania Supreme Court determined that the doctrine of “interspousal immunity,” which had barred a spouse from recovering against another spouse, was an antiquated doctrine which had lost its usefulness in modern society. The Court specifically found that a spouse could recover for injuries sustained as a result of another spouse’s negligence.

Over the years, I have successfully litigated several cases in which I represented a spouse in a personal injury case. In each of these cases, my client was seriously injured and required ongoing care and treatment. The bottom line is that if you are injured in an accident with your spouse, an attorney should investigate whether the spouse was negligent. 
 

Hidden Camera Reveals Elder Abuse

Recently, two employees were charged with abusing a dementia patient at Quadrangle Community at Sunrise Senior Living. The abuse was caught on a hidden camera set up by the victim’s family members. The camera, disguised as a clock, was placed in the victim’s room by the family after they suspected the abuse. The authorities have disclosed that the video shows that the 78-year old victim was topless while the “caretakers” taunted and tugged at the victims’ ears. Quadrangle is run by Sunrise Senior Living.


Unfortunately physical, mental and sexual abuse is a far too common occurrence at nursing homes and assisted living facilities. At Stark & Stark we have a proven track record of go after the individual as well as the facility in cases of abuse. If you have any suspicion that your loved one may be a victim of intentional abuse or inadvertent neglect please call me at 267-907-9600.   

The Impact of Nurse Staffing and Workloads on Patient Mortality

In my blogs I have previously written about matters related to nurse patient ratios. A recent study on nurse staffing was reported in Science Daily on March 16, 2011 in an article entitled “Risk of Hospital Patient Mortality Increases With Nurse Staffing Shortfalls, Study Finds”. The original study was published in the New England Journal of Medicine issued March 17, 2011.

The study was noteworthy in that the statistical analysis that was performed addressed criticisms of earlier studies. The study examined 198,000 patient admissions and 177,000 8 hour shifts at one major hospital. Staffing levels were linked to 48 different units on the hospital.

Two findings are noteworthy. First, patient mortality was linked to nurse staffing levels. Specifically, when a shift was deemed understaffed by nurses, falling 8 or more hours below a targeted level, risk of death increased by 2 %. Second, when patient turnover is substantially higher than usual” on a particular unit, risk of death also increases. In the study this translated into a 4 % higher risk of mortality.
 

Medicare Overview

Medicare is a health insurance plan for people who are over 65 and people who are disabled.  The program helps with the cost of health care, but it does not cover all medical expenses or the cost of most long-term care.  If you contemplating retiring and receiving Social Security Retirement benefits, you should think about Medicare coverage. 

If you choose to receive your Social Security benefits at or after age 62, you will not be eligible for Medicare until you are 65.  Once you reach age 65, whether or not you receive Social Security retirement benefits (because your full retirement age is 66 or 67, or because you choose to continue to work and delay your retirement to a later age) you can still receive Medicare coverage.  Several months before your 65th birthday you should sign up for Medicare.  You can do this by contacting your local Social Security office or on-line.